.
Feedback

Bully Birds, the Unexpected Garden Guests

I finally have the garden I've always dreamed of---and a few guests I didn't invite. Any tips for getting unwanted birds to fly the coop?

After years of backyard garden envy, my family and I can finally look out our back door at an-almost complete park-like setting of paths, flowering plants, vibrant vines clinging to the fence, a somewhat edible vegetable garden, and my favorite---a bird feeder.

There's nothing as simple yet satisfying as having small birds visit regularly after years of ignoring your property's existence. I even have a laminated "guide to Bay Area birds" near my window to help identify the little guys as they swoop in for some seed.  Even my cats, whom I feared would scare them off, have become lazy bird watchers themselves.

But as summer eases on, a new crop of winged warriors has arrived and taken control of the bird feeder, bird bath, and every tree top and fence post within sight of my little oasis. They are loud, obnoxious, and although absolutely gorgeous to look at, incredibly mean--they scare all the other birds, and even the squirrels away. (I can't help but wonder if the creators of the Angry Birds phone had a few of these monsters in mind when they designed those menacing animated faces.)

A bit of research, (thanks AllAboutBirds.org!) tells me these are Western Scrub Jays and probably Stellar's Jays---both characterized by their brilliant blue feathers and "assertive, vocal, and inquisitive" behaviors as well as their patrol posts set up high in trees, wires or posts waiting to swoop down into backyards, where they are quick to spy bird feeders as well as unattended picnic items. Ah ha!

Although these jays deserve as happy an existence as the other birds, I don't want them in my yard. They are the bullies of the bird world and have scared off all the other Disney-like critters who have been stopping by. Plus, they are ravenous. I filled the feeder to the brim on Friday morning---it's more than half gone by Sunday, and don't blame the squirrels.

So what do I do to protect the little guys who really do rely on my feeder for sustenance and my cypress trees for resting? Shooing the jays away vocally is getting me nowhere, and throwing things seems cruel. (My son suggested a slingshot.) And Nellie, the dog, just sleeps through their squawking visits. Do I just wait for them to tire of my Target-brand bird seed and hope they'll find some more interesting chow elsewhere? Or do I just learn to peacefully coexist with these blue bombers?

I'm open to suggestions from you bird-lovers out there. And in the meantime I'll have my garden hose poised in just such a way....

RecruiterMan August 27, 2012 at 12:29 pm
I found this link from a store. Since it's in Los Gatos, you may want to give them a call.
http://losgatosbirdwatcher.com/downloads/charts-and-flyers/LGB_Feeder-Seed_Chart.pdf Hope it helps!
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) August 27, 2012 at 12:36 pm
Thanks Charles...I'll check it out!
Janet Dahl August 27, 2012 at 01:45 pm
Have you tried a shiny object (pinwheel), wind chime, fake owl or snake? Also, larger birds can be deterred by enclosing your feeders in a cage. The smaller birds can get through the narrow openings and eat. Or get a smaller feeder with smaller perch.
Good luck! Love the pictures!
Bob Winters August 27, 2012 at 01:50 pm
Hanging old DVD/CDs with fishing line works well too.
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) August 27, 2012 at 02:14 pm
Thanks for all the suggestions---I will give the CD's a shot and I can manually shorten the perch on the feeder. Great ideas!
Judie Davis August 27, 2012 at 02:25 pm
I had to change the bird seed I use. I now only put out Nyjer seed (little tiny black seeds) which I get at Birder's Garden in San Carlos. The jays don't seem to like them but the cute little birds love them. I also have a suet feeder that the jays don't seem to care for either. Your yard is lovely.
1Diane August 27, 2012 at 04:42 pm
Hi Joan! I'm with Judie; I only have feeders that use the tiny Nyjer thistle seed. The openings on these feeders are teeny and only the small birds can retrieve them. (The bigger birds will still make their presence known occasionally because, you know, they're bullies.) Using bigger seeds not only attracts those bully birds and squirrels. After a while you will most likely see other uninvited rodents (ewwww) that also want a piece of the action. If you do purchase a thistle seed feeder, avoid the netted versions and get one of the hard plastic tube versions instead. I've had the nets torn to shreds once by a raccoon and once by one of the uninvited vermin. Also be careful how and where you store your seed because the vermin can easily get through the plastic bag it may come in. I use a metal container to keep them out.
Dan August 27, 2012 at 05:35 pm
I use a feeder with a small, narrow perch at the bottom. The smaller birds can land on it no problem. The jays end up trying to land but their wings are too large, they grab the side with their claws, and then end up hanging upside down - amusing to watch! The end result is they mostly go elsewhere, perhaps to the author's yard instead. But, even the little birds (finches and chickadees) can empty the feeder in just over a day.
Olga August 27, 2012 at 07:52 pm
1. I Russia these blue birds are called "Bird of Happines", means these birds are suppose to bring a Happy Life to you, so be nice to them :)
2. Easy solution would be a simple metal net like a cage around your bird feeder- this way only small birds can go in there and get the food :) you can do one yourself , since I have not seen any for sale. Bully birds will stop guarding the food as soon as they learn they can not get to it :)
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) August 27, 2012 at 08:31 pm
Thank you Olga....I promise, I will be nice to them, as they are just doing what comes naturally :) I'll try the metallic cage netting around the feeder as well as some of the distracting devices suggested by other readers. So glad to have such bird experts out there in Patchland!
sister madly August 28, 2012 at 12:01 am
what? only some birds deserve food? ugh. it's called NATURE. deal with it!
Angela August 29, 2012 at 02:03 am
Hello We have the scrub jays in our yard as well but we feed them unsalted peanuts as well as the squirrels and crows. We then have feeders for the smaller birds away from where we feed the jays etc. Good luck. Scrub jays are very smart and they get to know you. One will follow my husband when he is outside bbq until he gets some peanuts.
Good Luck
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) August 29, 2012 at 11:17 am
Wow....so that explains why I've found some peanuts in my yard! Thanks for the advice Angela. They are smart and I have noticed they are very aware of the humans' presence. Maybe I'll try the peanut trick, far from the smaller bird feeder and see if that makes them happy---that way we can coexist peacefully without me having to chase them away.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Belmont Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
George Metropulos June 19, 2013 at 12:42 pm
First thing I would ask is who did you talk you, and have you followed up? Was this something youRead More got in writing? Did they give you a timeline that has lapsed?
Steve Hayes June 19, 2013 at 12:54 pm
The practical solution - just paint it yourself. Sounds like a very small job and the City alreadyRead More agreed it is a good idea.
George Metropulos June 19, 2013 at 12:59 pm
Do you really think the city is waiting for someone to get killed?
Michele Moyer June 16, 2013 at 09:17 am
Thanks Joan - there is one in the sub-head of the blog I posted on School-Force Voices today; wouldRead More love if it could be corrected. Been scratching my head til I saw this post :)
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) June 16, 2013 at 11:20 am
Sorry about that! There's nothing I can do on my end----it's system-wide bug, which I believe isRead More fixed now. :)
Belmont96 June 13, 2013 at 09:40 am
I also preferred the 'old' Patch - this format makes it difficult to find articles that are aren'tRead More that old. One example was the informative article on who was running for city Council. I was having problems finding it and finally had to query on a candidate's name to find. I don't recall having that issue with the original format. Also our neighborhood had a water break line and we were without water for some hours a few Sundays ago. I tried to find out the reason for the break (because of construction or old pipes?) and could not find anything on the Patch regarding this. Not sure if they just didn't report or I just couldn't find.
Judi June 14, 2013 at 07:28 am
Not crazy about the new Patch either. Also, I want to post-for sale, and this section is crowdedRead More with announcements, etc.
Pearl June 14, 2013 at 04:15 pm
Another thing that needs to be fixed: When you go to leave a comment, it takes you over to whereRead More you have to sign in, you sign in expecting to be returned to the article on which you are commenting, but it, instead, takes you back to some different article. PLEASE FIX THIS!!!! Also, please reinstate the feature where we can sign up to be notified if/when more comments are made concerning the article(s) we've commented on so we can follow the conversation. Thank you.
Christa Bigue (Editor) June 10, 2013 at 01:50 pm
Thanks Sam! You should also post this Half Moon Bay (halfmoonbay.patch.com) and Pacifica PatchRead More (pacifica.patch.com)! I'm sure our readers would appreciate the great tip!
Michael Williams June 9, 2013 at 04:12 pm
Strongly suggest Patch readers check all the YELP reviews of this business. Very uneven experiencesRead More reported.
don torre June 4, 2013 at 06:55 am
what do the local Belmont restaurants think of this? do these people pay a license to the city?
Joan S. Dentler (Editor) June 4, 2013 at 07:15 am
Hi Don....thanks for your question. Yes, Off the Grid does pay a licensing fee to the city, and soRead More far, we haven't heard any concerns by local restaurants. The food trucks provide an option to a traditional restaurant---pick up and go----and they are only around 4-5 hours per week (on Mondays, typically not a big restaurant night anyway). Have you tried the food yet?